Mexican Cheese Substitutes
You’ve just downloaded and printed a killer Mexican recipe, but your local market just doesn’t carry that special cheese. Use this list of common substitutions. Most pinpoint the texture and others are close to the taste.
Disclaimer: Cow’s milk just doesn’t taste like goat’s milk, but these are the best substitutions.
QUESO OAXACA
The best substitute: buffalo mozzarella, sprinkled with extra salt.
QUESO FRESCO
(Queso Ranchero)
Best substitute: Paneer with added salt or very mild feta (French or Danish style).
QUESO REQUESÓN
Best substitute: Cream ricotta
QUESO COTIJA
Best substitute: Ricotta Salata or (in a pinch) Parmesan
QUESO ASADERO
Best substitutes: Provolone (young variety)
QUESO CHIHUAHUA
Best substitutes: Cheddar or Monterrey Jack
QUESO PANELA
Best substitutes: Paneer, halloumi or hard ricotta
QUESO MANCHEGO
Best substitutes: fresh Pecorino, Gouda, Havarti or mild cheddar